Skip to content

Client Update: Future CPP disability benefits are deductible under the SEF 44 in Nova Scotia

In an important case for insurance practice in Nova Scotia, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that the value of future CPP disability benefits is deductible under the SEF 44 family protection endorsement.

Justice Scanlan wrote the unanimous reasons in Portage LaPrairie Mutual Insurance Company v Sabean, 2015 NSCA 53 [“Sabean“].

The very purpose of the SEF 44 was crucial to the result in this case. Recall that this endorsement provides additional coverage for an insured, in the case of a motor vehicle accident with an underinsured motorist. As the Court of Appeal emphasized in the earlier case of Campbell-MacIsaac v Deveaux, 2004 NSCA 87, the SEF 44 is “excess” insurance, beyond the minimum coverage mandated by the Insurance Act. It has also been called “last ditch” and “safety net” insurance.

According to Justice Scanlan in Sabean, the nature of the SEF 44 as “an excess coverage provision” is a key part of the context when interpreting the endorsement.

The particular provision at issue here was clause 4(b)(vii):

  1. The amount payable under this endorsement to any eligible claimant is excess to any amount actually recovered by the eligible claimant from any source (other than money payable on death under a policy of insurance) and is excess to any amounts the eligible claimant is entitled to recover (whether such entitlement is pursued or not) from:

    1. any policy of insurance providing disability benefits or loss of income benefits or medical expense or rehabilitation benefits;

The Court of Appeal agreed that CPP disability benefits are a “policy of insurance providing disability benefits” and therefore have to be deducted under this provision. Otherwise, the insured claimant would be “double dipping”, contrary to the purpose of the SEF 44 as excess insurance only.

With the release of Sabean, there is now a clear divide between the law in Nova Scotia and the law in New Brunswick on this issue. In Economical Mutual Insurance Co v Lapalme, 2010 NBCA 87, the New Brunswick Court of Appeal reached the opposite conclusion from the Court of Appeal in Sabean, and held that future CPP disability benefits are not to be deducted under New Brunswick’s version of the SEF 44. The NSCA expressly declined to follow Lapalme.

Congratulations to Scott Norton, Q.C., Scott Campbell, and Jennifer Taylor, all of Stewart McKelvey, who successfully represented the appellant in this case.

The foregoing is intended for general information only. If you have any questions or require further information on how this applies to your business, visit our Insurance practice group. For more on our firm, visit www.stewartmckelvey.com.

SHARE

Archive

Search Archive


 
 

Client Update: Automobile Tort Recovery Limitations Regulations Repealed

September 28, 2015

As of August 1, 2015, section 4 of the Nova Scotia Automobile Tort Recovery Limitations Regulations was repealed. This section previously set the discount rate for future losses in automobile tort claims at 3.5%. The repeal…

Read More

Client Update: Nova Scotia Consultation on Pooled Registered Pension Plan (PRPP) Regulations

September 11, 2015

On September 9, 2015, the Nova Scotia Department of Finance and Treasury Board opened a consultation on draft Regulations for Pooled Registered Pension Plans (PRPPs). The draft Regulations and an FAQ are posted online. PRPPs are…

Read More

Back to (Limitations) School: Nova Scotia’s new Limitation of Actions Act in force September 1st

September 1, 2015

By Jennifer Taylor – Research Lawyer September used to mean one thing: back to school. This year, Nova Scotia lawyers get a fresh learning opportunity of a different sort. It comes in the form of the new Limitation…

Read More

Atlantic Employers’ Counsel – Summer 2015

August 24, 2015

THE EDITORS’ CORNER Michelle Black and Sean Kelly Aaah, summer – that long anticipated stretch of lazy, lingering days, free of responsibility and rife with possibility. It’s a time to hunt for insects, master handstands, practice swimming…

Read More

Client Update: Government of Canada Improvements to Procurement Integrity Provisions

July 13, 2015

The New Public Contracting World As part of an ongoing initiative aimed at ensuring Canada only does business with ethical suppliers, Public Works and Government Services Canada (“PWGSC”) has introduced changes to its Integrity Regime…

Read More

Client Update: Future CPP disability benefits are deductible under the SEF 44 in Nova Scotia

June 4, 2015

In an important case for insurance practice in Nova Scotia, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that the value of future CPP disability benefits is deductible under the SEF 44 family protection endorsement. Justice Scanlan wrote the…

Read More

Client Update: Changes to the Venture Issuer Regime Effective June 30, 2015

May 13, 2015

In order to streamline the continuous disclosure obligations of venture issuers, the Canadian Securities Administrators (“CSA”) are implementing amendments to the national instruments and companion policies listed below, that will come into force across Canada…

Read More

Client Update: New Nova Scotia Pension Benefits Act and Regulations effective June 1, 2015

April 23, 2015

On April 21, 2015, the Nova Scotia government declared that the new Pension Benefits Act (passed in 2011) and new Pension Benefits Regulations will come into effect on June 1, 2015. The new Regulations follow the new Act and draft Regulations summarized in…

Read More

Client Update: A Return to Reasonableness – Assessing Damages after Section D Settlements

April 4, 2015

An uninsured driver strikes another vehicle, injuring its occupants. These injured persons obtain a settlement from their own motor vehicle insurer (pursuant to Section D of the standard policy), and they assign their action against…

Read More

Atlantic Employers’ Counsel – Spring 2015

March 26, 2015

The Editors’ Corner Michelle Black and Sean Kelly Hello! We are very pleased to be the new Atlantic Employers’ Counsel (AEC) editors. We look forward to bringing you what we hope you will find to be interesting…

Read More

Search Archive


Scroll To Top