Skip to content

Court upholds mandatory vaccine policy – Placing employee on unpaid leave not constructive dismissal

Mark Tector and Ben Currie

While there have been a number of arbitration decisions on the subject, Parmar v Tribe Management Inc., 2022 BCSC 1675 appears to be the first reported civil court decision to consider whether placing a non-unionized employee on an unpaid leave of absence for failure to comply with a mandatory vaccination policy (“MVP”) is constructive dismissal.

Ultimately, the Court found that the MVP was a reasonable response to the COVID-19 pandemic and Ms. Parmar made the choice not to comply with it; therefore, she was not constructively dismissed.

One way constructive dismissal occurs is where an employer makes a single unilateral change that substantially alters an essential term of the employment contract. In this context, the Court determined this issue by considering whether Tribe Management Inc.’s (“Tribe”) unilateral decision to place Ms. Parmar on unpaid leave for failure to comply with the MVP was reasonable and justified.

Tribe provides condominium management services. Ms. Parmar was an accounting professional working for Tribe with nineteen (19) years of experience in the industry. Tribe notified its employees on October 5, 2021 of its MVP and required employees to be fully vaccinated by November 24, 2021. Of Tribe’s 200 employees, only Ms. Parmar and one other employee failed to comply by the deadline. She did not claim to have a medical or religious exemption.

Ms. Parmar did not consider herself an “anti-vaxxer”, but explained that she reviewed the literature and was skeptical of the efficacy and side effects of the available vaccines. She also described that her family members experienced several adverse symptoms from the vaccine.

Ms. Parmar proposed several alternatives including working entirely from home, or on a hybrid basis with controlled visits to the office to sign cheques. She also offered to undergo frequent testing, but Tribe reiterated that the only exceptions were for medical or religious accommodation. Ms. Parmar was placed on an unpaid leave for three (3) months from December 1, 2021 to February 28, 2022. On January 25, 2022, Tribe advised Ms. Parmar that she would remain on unpaid leave until she became vaccinated or the MVP was relaxed. Ms. Parmar announced her resignation the next day and considered her employment constructively dismissed.

The Court made the following findings in reaching its decision that the MVP was reasonable and that Ms. Parmar was not constructively dismissed:

  • The assessment of the reasonableness of the MVP must be considered based on the knowledge about the pandemic at the time it was implemented and in light of Tribe’s obligation to protect its employees and clients;
  • Interestingly, the Court took judicial notice that COVID-19 is potentially deadly, easily transmissible, symptoms vary by person, and that vaccines reduce the severity of symptoms and adverse outcomes despite not preventing infection or transmission;
  • The MVP reflected the employer’s statutory obligation to ensure the health and safety of all workers;
  • “Individual views of the appropriateness of the MVP do not undermine the reasonableness of the policy”;
  • Parmar’s employment contract expressly stated that she would comply with all of Tribe’s policies as amended at Tribe’s discretion, subject to the policies being lawful and reasonable;
  • Tribe did not intend to terminate Ms. Parmar’s employment as she was a valued employee and expected to return to her new role, which she was recently promoted into; and
  • Implementing a MVP was a reasonable policy choice for employers based on the extraordinary circumstance of the pandemic in October of 2021 into January of 2022 and was the prevailing approach at the time.

As the first reported decision on the enforceability of MVPs in the non-union context, this case is significant. While we will have to wait to see if other Courts in different provinces follow this approach, it is good news for other employers who have implemented MVPs, including MVPs which result in employees being placed on unpaid leaves.  It is also significant the Court took judicial notice that (1) COVID-19 is serious and potentially deadly; and (2) that vaccines are an important and effective tool in reducing the potential harm.


This client update is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you have any questions about the above, please contact a member of our Labour and Employment group.

Click here to subscribe to Stewart McKelvey Thought Leadership.

SHARE

Archive

Search Archive


 
 

Anticipating changes to the Competition Act: what businesses need to know

November 1, 2023

By Deanne MacLeod, K.C., Burtley Francis & David Slipp On September 21, 2023, the Federal Government introduced Bill C-56: An Act to amend the Excise Tax Act and the Competition Act (“Bill C-56”), with the…

Read More

Powering the future: Green choice program regulations

September 22, 2023

By Nancy Rubin, K.C. and Lauren Agnew The long-awaited Green Choice Program Regulations (N.S. Reg. 155/2023) were released by the provincial government on September 8, 2023, offering some clarity into the practical implementation of Nova…

Read More

Privilege protected: Court of Appeal rules NL’s Information and Privacy Commissioner barred from reviewing solicitor-client privileged information

September 20, 2023

By Koren Thomson, John Samms, and Matthew Raske The Newfoundland and Labrador Court of Appeal has held that the Information and Privacy Commissioner for this province (the “Commissioner”) does not have the authority to order…

Read More

Amendments required for Prince Edward Island code of conduct bylaws

September 18, 2023

By Perlene Morrison, K.C. Municipalities are required to pass code of conduct bylaws in accordance with section 107 of the Municipal Government Act (the “MGA”). Subsection 107(1) of the MGA specifically states that a municipality’s…

Read More

Professionally speaking: Ontario Superior Court upholds professional regulators’ right to moderate speech

September 14, 2023

By Sheila Mecking and Kathleen Starke On August 23, 2023, the Ontario Superior Court (“ONSC”) upheld a complaints decision which ordered a psychologist to complete a continuing education or remedial program regarding professionalism in public…

Read More

One-year reminder for federal employers: Pay equity plans due September 3, 2024

September 5, 2023

By Dante Manna As we advised in a previous podcast, all federal employers with at least ten employees[1] have been subject to the Pay Equity Act [2] (“PEA”) and Pay Equity Regulations [3] (“Regulations”) since…

Read More

Charging to net-zero: Government releases draft Clean Electricity Regulations

August 23, 2023

By Nancy Rubin, K.C. Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) recently published a draft of the Clean Electricity Regulations (CER). The proposed Regulations work toward achieving a net-zero electricity-generating sector, helping Canada become a net-zero…

Read More

Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador rejects developer’s constructive expropriation claim

August 18, 2023

By Stephen Penney & Matthew Raske In the recent decision Index Investment Inc. v. Paradise (Town), 2023 NLSC 112, the Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador validated the Town of Paradise’s decision to rezone lands…

Read More

IRCC expands authorization for foreign workers to study without a study permit: Four things you need to know

July 13, 2023

By Sara Espinal Henao Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (“IRCC”) has announced a promising new temporary measure that allows foreign workers to study for a longer duration without a study permit, opening the door for…

Read More

Canada’s first-ever Tech Talent Strategy announced

July 12, 2023

By Brendan Sheridan The Government of Canada recently announced a number of aggressive immigration measures to help attract top talent to Canada in high-growth industries in an effort to fuel innovation and drive emerging technologies.…

Read More

Search Archive


Scroll To Top