Skip to content

New Brunswick introduces prompt payment and adjudication legislation

By Conor O’Neil and Maria Cummings

On May 9, 2023, two bills were introduced in the New Brunswick Legislature that could have material affects on the construction industry. Bills 41 and 42, of the current session, if passed, would amend the Construction Remedies Act, and introduce a new companion act which would establish mandatory prompt payment and adjudication for construction projects. As of the writing of this article, both bills are working through the legislature and will not become law unless passed in this session.

Bill 41, an Act respecting holdback trust accounts

Bill 41, if passed, will amend the Construction Remedies Act to repeal the requirement for an owner to maintain a holdback trust account for each improvement with a joint trustee. The requirement to maintain holdback by an owner will remain but the practical effect will be to return to the practice under the historical Mechanics’ Lien Act whereby an owner is not required to deposit the holdback into a separate trust account.

Bill 42, Construction Prompt Payment and Adjudication Act

Bill 42, if passed, will introduce a completely new act, the Construction Prompt Payment and Adjudication Act (the “Act”). The application of the Act is defined almost identically to the Construction Remedies Act. In other words, it will apply to almost any construction contract, although there is potentially broad authority to exempt certain classes of improvements, persons or contracts in the regulations. Its effect will be to introduce a new regime including prompt payment and adjudication.

Prompt payment legislation is aimed at the perception of systemic slow or non-payment in the construction industry. The first Canadian prompt payment bill was introduced in Ontario in 2017. Since then prompt payment and adjudication legislation has been considered in a majority of provinces, and federally, many of which have introduced and passed their own bills, although it is not in force in every jurisdiction in which a bill has been introduced.

The prompt payment portion of the Act prescribes time periods in which payment must flow through the construction pyramid. After the delivery of a “proper invoice” by a contractor to an owner, the owner has 28 days in which it must pay the proper invoice. The owner may dispute the proper invoice by issuing a notice of non-payment within 14 days of receipt of the proper invoice. Even if a notice of non-payment is issued, the owner must pay the undisputed portion of the proper invoice within the same 28-day window.

The time period for payment cascades down the construction pyramid through direct contracting parties. For example, upon receipt of payment on the 28th day by the contractor, that contractor then has 7 days in which to provide payment to its subcontractor(s) (i.e. by day 35). Similarly, upon receipt of payment by a subcontractor it must pay its sub-subcontractors or suppliers within 7 days (i.e. by day 42).

Adjudication provides the teeth to enforce prompt payment. A common criticism of traditional dispute resolution processes, like litigation or arbitration, is that they are too slow and disputes choke off the cash flow necessary for projects to continue on to completion. Adjudication provides a new option that has been described as an interim-binding dispute resolution.

The Act provides that much of the actual process for adjudication will be set out in the regulations, or by the adjudicator nominating authority. However, in other jurisdictions the intent has been that where there is a dispute as to payment that dispute may be referred to a third-party adjudicator and a decision on the dispute may be rendered in as little as 39 to 60 days. The concept is that the decision of the adjudicator is only binding on the parties to a dispute until the project is substantially performed. In theory, this increases cash flow and provides an interim mechanism for the parties to complete the project. Parties that are unhappy with the result of an adjudication are free to litigate or arbitrate after the fact.

Other provinces have taken varied approaches to the appointment of an adjudicator nominating authority and the training and certification of adjudicators. The regime as a whole has been met with mixed reviews on its success. Prompt payment and adjudication is still in its infancy across Canada and it remains to be seen how this could be effectively implemented in New Brunswick.


This client update is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you have any questions about the above, please contact the authors.

Click here to subscribe to Stewart McKelvey Thought Leadership.

SHARE

Archive

Search Archive


 
 

Client Update: Consistent Use: The Collection of Union Members’ Personal Information by their Unions

February 10, 2014

The Public Service Labour Relations Board concluded that an employer was required to provide home contact information about bargaining unit members to the union which represents them because this information is needed by the union…

Read More

Client Update: Outlook for the 2014 Proxy Season

February 5, 2014

In preparing for the 2014 proxy season, you should be aware of some regulatory changes that may impact disclosure to and interactions with your shareholders. This update highlights what is new in the 2014 proxy…

Read More

Client Update: Torts: Unlawful Interference with Economic Relations

February 4, 2014

In a decision released by the Supreme Court of Canada (“the Court”) on January 31, 2014, the Court clarified the law with respect to the tort of interference with economic relations by unlawful means. Joyce,…

Read More

Client Update: 2013 Labour & Employment Atlantic Canada Legislative Update

December 23, 2013

As we move into 2014, we know our region’s employers will want to be aware of new legislation that has passed or could soon pass that may affect them. The following is what has become…

Read More

Client Update: New Forms of Unpaid Leave under Newfoundland and Labrador Labour Standards Act

December 12, 2013

What’s new? Our employer clients will be familiar with the Labour Standards Act, which sets out the employment standards applicable in Newfoundland and Labrador. Two amendments were made to the legislation this week, both of which…

Read More

Client Update: First Contract Arbitration

December 9, 2013

As many of you will now know, the Nova Scotia Government introduced legislation on Friday, December 6, 2013, amending provisions of the Nova Scotia Trade Union Act dealing with First Contract Arbitration. This client update sets out…

Read More

Client Update: Supreme Court of Canada confirms that international organization enjoys immunity from wrongful dismissal suit commenced by senior employee

December 4, 2013

In a decision that will largely be of interest to international organizations that have been granted some type of immunity in Canada, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) has confirmed that international organizations enjoy immunity…

Read More

Client Update: Time to Update Workplace Policies in PEI

December 2, 2013

The Prince Edward Island (“PEI”) legislature has proposed changes to the PEI Human Rights Act to add “gender expression” and “gender identity” as new protected grounds of discrimination. First introduced on November 13, 2013 the…

Read More

Client Update: December 2 deadline for responses on changes to PEI Auto Insurance

November 25, 2013

We previously circulated a client update regarding contemplated changes to automobile insurance in Prince Edward Island. Government has now published a consultation paper (www.gov.pe.ca/photos/original/eljautoinreform.pdf), seeking responses in writing on or before December 2, 2013. According to the consultation…

Read More

Caribbean Corporate Counsel – Winter 2013

November 19, 2013

The Association of Caribbean Corporate Counsel (ACCC) released the inaugural edition of its quarterly journal, Caribbean Corporate Counsel, featuring CEO, John Rogers, Q.C., advisor on the International Advisory Board, and an article by partner Paul Smith, entitled “Governance…

Read More

Search Archive


Scroll To Top